A PLACE OF USEFUL LEARNING
Edinburgh: 25 (20) Glasgow Warriors: 32 (12)
I have reached the stage in life when the young folk in the family are contemplating university education. A strong candidate is the University of Strathclyde. I've always liked that institution's strapline - A Place Of Useful Learning. While many may feel that PPE has rarely generated individuals who are really up to running a country, there is undoubtedly a place for arts degrees and learning for its own sake. But Strathclyde focuses on subjects whose application in the real world is intensely practical. Led by the great Professor Sir Jim McDonald, it is an institution that makes things happen, as the regeneration of its corner of central Glasgow testifies.
After no-side at BT Murrayfield last night - or, at least, after the red mist had lifted - I contemplated the progress that Glasgow Warriors have made so far this season. How quickly Franco Smith has remodeled them into something that looks to my eyes more like the Glasgow of old - thrilling in the wider channels, but able to hold their own and spoil up front. They have a long way still to go to be as competitive as they were in the past. But their learning under Smith has been useful and we are seeing a difference in the real world.
It would have been a big surprise had Sione Tuipolotu not won the Player of the Match Award at the end of this tussle. It was his ability to break the line repeatedly in attack that was at the heart of the Warriors' bonus point win. The Gunners slipped off too many tackles, granted, but the threequarter is one of those guys who it is tough to take down. That was about power and pace. But he also gave his side a strong lead in a match where it was the leaders on the Glasgow side who really stood up to drive them to victory when it really counted in the final quarter. Skipper Kyle Steyn had an effective outing in a back three that outshone their oppositive numbers, while Tom Jordan controlled the game beautifully in the finishing straight. Ali Price may be struggling for form a little, but George Horne made a big difference - perhaps a decisive one - when he came in in the second half.
The Embramen © , by contrast, looked like the bright kid who never really had to work too hard at school, but struggles in the different environment of university life, where most folk are as bright as you and you need to graft to keep up. They are going through a difficult run at the moment and they will get through it. But they are repeating the same failings from week to week, rather than addressing them, notably their inability to take enough chances when they arise. Nor, as Mike 'Blade' Blair said in the build up to the 1872 match this week, do they keep their foot on the opposition's throat when they have the advantage. They had a handy 20-12 lead at the break, which was boosted by the supremely clinical winning of a scrum penalty in injury time to set up Emiliano 'The Boff' Boffelli for the three pointer. That should have been a match-winning position. But instead it was the Warriors who took control and outscored their hosts 20-5 in the second period. It was positive that the Gunners fought hard to salvage a losing bonus point with Harrison's late try and gave themselves a faint glimmer of securing three points had they scored a converted bonus point try for the draw immediately afterwards. But it was the guddle in their own 22 in the final play of the match that really summed up their performance.
Injuries clearly haven't helped and some of Edinburgh's main men are not yet back to their best. The King Blairhorn did not look himself at all, while 'Big' Bill Mata had some immense carries, but came off early and looked tired. Around the hour mark, many of the team looked knackered, in fact. Glasgow didn't allow them to play the game they wanted to when it mattered anyway, and one felt that the Gunners should have got Duhan van der Merwe into the game much more than they did before he retired with an injury. On a brighter note, young Harry Paterson had another strong outing in attack and defence, while El Rey has clearly rediscovered his kicking trousers, keeping the scoreboard ticking while looking the Gunners' most threatening back in attack.
I don't share the view of some professional scribes that this was a high quality match. That's partly down to sour grapes. But I don't think the conditions during the match were so bad that they justified the number of handling and kicking errors we were subjected to. Both sides waxed and waned at lineout and set piece, but the breakdown was a mess. The only real glimpses of light were in Steyn, Jordan and Horne's tries. For that alone, the Warriors deserved to win. One other positive was that, despite everything the elements could throw at them and the public transport network, 25,000 Ultras on both sides made it to BT Murrayfield.
And Glasgow got off to a flyer. Steyn shrugging off three tacklers to cross after good work from his forwards. 0-7 Glasgow after five minutes, Jordan having nailed the wide conversion.
But Edinburgh hit back quickly. Price's attempt to clear deep in his own 22 was charged down and home co-skipper Jamie Ritchie took advantage of the error under pressure to drive over to tie things up with El Rey's conversion on 10 minutes. The Boff added three points on 16 minutes after the Warriors were pinged for a ruck offence following a great carry by BBM into the enemy 22. The Embramen © were turning the screw and Cancelliere brilliantly denied van der Merwe in the corner, holding up the international winner to deny what looked like an odds-on score as the first quarter came to an end.
The home pressure was rewarded soon after, though, as they rumbled an attacking lineout maul over. The returning Skinner took the throw in and the pack drove for Luke 'Bing' Crosbie to flop over the line on 27 minutes. 17-7 Embra and they were well on top. Fagerson junior did pull back an unconverted score off a Glasgow maul, but The Boff's penalty at the stroke of half time left the Gunners handily placed with a 20-12 lead. The 1872 Cup was metaphorically in their hands as they were up by eight points on aggregate.
It looked like it might be same again in the second half as Fraser Brown had to look lively to steal Edinburgh ball on his own line, while the Gunners' defence seemed to have the Warriors under control. But the wheels started to come off when Glasgow scored a great try from distance on 56 minutes. They took advantage of the narrow home defence on halfway, both Siones combining well with Cancelliere on the right wing before putting the supporting Jordan over for the score, converted by himself to narrow the gap to 20-19. Now the pressure was on a tiring Edinburgh side and they weren't coping particularly well.
On 67 minutes, 'Eric' Sykes was carded for being offside at a ruck, Horne putting Glasgow ahead with the successful penalty. The visitors were 20-22 up going into the final 10 minutes with a man advantage. They made it count immediately, with Steyn gathering a kick behind the defence, feeding Jordan who found the supporting Horne for the Warriors' fourth try of the night and a nine point lead that looked devilishly difficult for the Embramen © to claw back. It looked even more challening once Horne had knocked over another penalty on 74 minutes. 20-32 down with five minutes to run. Realistically, this one was now about salvaging a losing bonus.
To their credit, Edinburgh did dig in and knocked a late penalty to the corner. Harrison scored an acrobatic try in the corner just before time had expired, but it was too little too late. Two Inter-City games, a mere two URC points the return. However you look at it, that's not good enough.
There has been some debate about who might be Scotland's national coach after next year's World Cup, should Gregor Townsend move 'upstairs', Telfer-like, to another role in the SRU. If that does indeed come to pass, Mike Blair is clearly being developed as a candidate. I will be surprised if he does not end up with the big job at some point as he seems destined for it. His frank and insightful comments in interview after the match were typical of a level headed, smart coach. For what it's worth, though, I think he needs more experience at pro level, which would suggest Scotland need another candidate for the next World Cup cycle. While my own vote goes to Michael Cheika, one could see Franco Smith in that space. He certainly had the better of the coaching tussle yesterday evening.
So, not the best end to 2022 from a blue and burnt orange perspective. But 2022 as a whole has been pretty rubbish for all of us, so it's good to see the back of it. I wish you and all who are dear to you a very happy, healthy and prosperous 2023 when it comes.