BING BRINGS HOME THE WIN
Edinburgh: 31 (14) v Castres Olympique: 20 (13)
I don't know about you, but I don't like the new format for the Heineken Cup. I had assumed that the two pool structure was a temporary fix during Covid. Instead, it seems to have stuck and we're left with a confusing melange with two fewer pool matches, where different people play other people home and away on the basis of some kind of seeding system in massive pools. Has it got rid of the dead rubbers we used to see in the last two pool matches, where many no hopers gave up? Not really. If anything, clubs capitulate earlier in the competition than they used to do. It is still a magical competition, the pinnacle of the club game in Europe. And it's great to have the South African clubs adding something different. But I can't help but feel that the golden goose is starting to think that taking out some life insurance might be a prudent move.
Two things that haven't changed are that you have got to get off to a flyer and it is almost impossible to recover if you lose any home ties.This afternoon's Pool A match was therefore a must-win for both sides, each having lost their openers - the Embramen in a narrow 30-26 squeak away to Saracens, Castres 10-27 at home to Exeter. The Gunners were in a better position, having taken the minimum acceptable return from a road trip, namely a losing bonus. And they had played very well at the Stone-X, even if, as still happens too often, they had thrown the win away.
The home side were hit by a late call off on the wing, Hoyland coming in for Duhan van der Merwe. In other changes, WP was selected to win the usual scrum penalties at tighthead, while Glen Young joined Grant 'Gilcho' Gilchrist in the boiler room, with Matt Currie coming into centre threequarter in place of the injured Mark 'Benzo' Bennett. A much changed Castres Olympique squad suggested that they were already thinking more about the Top14, even if their performance rather belied that in the end. That this match was able to go ahead at all at the DAM Health, rather than the toasty warm BT Murrayfield hybrid surface, was down to the heroic efforts of the SRU groundstaff. Observers of a blue and burnt orange perspective expected a bonus point win. Would the Embramen deliver a similarly determined performance on a gorgeous festive afternoon?
It was mission accomplished against a second string Castres side at no-side. But they made awfully hard work of it. The Gunners' performance was an underwhelming one with plenty of room for improvement. The visitors hung in there and scored some cracking tries with the limited opportunities they had. For the ball and field position they had, Edinburgh really should have been out of sight after an hour. Early injuries to two key perfomers didn't help, nor did the baffling failure of a good referee to control the infringing of a Castres side who coughed up what could be a world record 23 penalties.
Playing into the wind and the setting sun, they were on top in the early stages, if a little loose. Blairhorn ran a penalty from the enemy 10 metre line, which took play close to the Castres line, but the Frenchmen managed to break beautifully, only for a poor pass at halfway to deny them a cracking try. While the Gunners' plan was clearly to move the big French pack around, a bit more care in execution was required. For example, on 13 minutes, when Edinburgh were again pressing on the Castres line, a hasty Vellacott pass went to ground and Blanc fly hacked the ball and chased, which was eventually well cleared into touch by Lang in the Gunners' 22. But the ever impressive 'Bing' Crosbie saved the day at the succeeding lineout and the Gunners worked their way back into the Castres 22. 15 minutes gone and Edinburgh had already lost both McInally and The King to injury, while they were living dangerously with their carelessness in attack.
The penalties were really mounting up for the visitors under pressure, mind. And from a tap penalty five metres out, Schoeman had a good breenge before 'Big' Bill Mata took the ball up at pace in space and ran over Botica for the first try as the first quarter came to a close. El Rey, Emiliano 'The Boff' Boffelli knocked the conversion over for a 7-0 advantage. The decision to run the straightforward penalty was ambitious, but the execution was sound this time.
For the first time in the match, Castres showed some urgency in attack. On 24 minutes, Colonna pounced on a stray lineout ball on the Gunners' 22 and shrugged off a few weak tackles to cross in the corner.
The visitors' penalty count continued to tick up, a theme of this match. The Boff knocked another one into the corner after the latest high shot to set up good attacking field position. But a strong set of forward drives counted for nothing as the Gunners' failure to support the man with the ball allowed Castres to win the breakdown penalty. They worked the ball to the other end of the park and Julien Blanc was on hand to pick up an offload for a great try on the half hour, despite a valiant tackle by Wes 'Moose' Goosen. A second failed conversion attempt left the deficit only 7-10, but Edinburgh needed to sharpen up. It didn't help that Castres had already conceded 10 penalties after half an hour.
The penalties continued to pile up and it was astonishing that referee Foley had not even warned the visitors after they racked up a dozen. He got his act together with the unlucky thirteenth on 36 minutes, though. The Gunners got their close in maul rumbling and only a blatant Kornath collapse of the maul stopped a try. Mr Foley managed to card the wrong man, a bemused Walcker, but there could be no argument about the penalty try. The score was 14-13 Edinburgh at the break after Dumora had slotted a penalty kick for the short-handed French outfit.
In a finely balanced affair, Castres' rope-a-dope strategy was keeping them in the contest while the Gunners were lacking just that little bit of veteran nous to take advantage of their superior possession and field position. James Lang, perhaps like The Sweet Price, Chris Dean, is one of those clever second five-eighths who always seems to get over the gain line and bring others into play. He'd had some fine runs in the first period. One felt that maybe he would prove crucial as a foil for Savala in the second, as did indeed prove to be the case.
After The Boff had uncharacteristically guddled a Lang offload with the line at his mercy, the top scorer in Test rugby in 2022 knocked yet another penalty into the corner to set up more attacking phases. The piano shifters up front pounded the line, with Crosbie featuring prominently with ball in hand, before the ball was shipped against the grain. Lang slipped the ball out the back to Savala for the multi-sport superstar to stroll over for Edinburgh's third try. An illustration of what these guys can do when they stay cool and everything clicks. 21-13 Edinburgh on 50 minutes as The Sweet Prince trotted on for the injured Currie.
The Gunners were starting to crank up the pace now and the referee gave Castres a warning as they coughed up penalty number 16. The Frenchmen sent their remaining six replacements on at the same time and it seemed to give them a boost as they enjoyed some pressure in the Edinburgh red zone. But the home defence held out, Jamie Ritchie turned over superbly and the Embramen won the penalty that enabled The Boff to clear the danger. Castres were enjoying a purple patch and the Gunners were having to work hard in defence to maintain their advantage as the match moved into the final quarter. Not least The Moose, who put in another cracking tackle on the wing to snuff out a dangerous visiting attack.
On 65 minutes, Dean sparked a thrilling breakout on the right wing. Lang took the ball on and kicked long into the in-goal area. One of those horrific guddles by Laveau attempting to touch down saw the full back miss the ball and the pursuing Vellacott touched down in the confusion. There were several million points for the TMO to check, but eventually the bonus point try was awarded. After the dust had settled, the Gunners were 28-13 ahead on 67 minutes.
You'd have thought with his side having been pinged going on for 20 times, replacement half back Rory Kockott might have thought twice about chirping at the referee in the wake of the score. But when the veteran turned his attention to the game, he created a gorgeous score for Securet. 28-20 and it was really time for the Gunners to kill this match off.
The last 10 minutes had its moments for both sides - and Castres notched the dubious distinction of being pinged for a twentieth time. Shortly after, most observers were in danger of hospitalisation as a result of excessive laughter when Castres gave up their 22nd penalty and referee Foley sternly warned them that 'there are getting too many' and that the next one would lead to a card! The Boff ended the match as a contest with a three pointer to leave the score 31-20 to the Embramen with only three more minutes left to run. A smart tactical move.
There was still time for a 23rd - count 'em - penalty for a blatant Guerois-Galisson slap out of the scrum half's hand at an attacking Edinburgh ruck. Utterly gobsmackingly, there was no yellow card, but the Gunners ran out bonus point winners to put them on 6 points. They will sit in a top eight placing after the first block of Heineken pool matches - they are fourth in Pool A at the time of typing. Four Heineken matches played so far today, four try bonus points. These things are incredibly important and could be the diference between qualifying or putting out the dirt trackers in the final match of the pool stage.
A well deserved Heineken Star of the Match was 'Bing' Crosbie. Mr Consistency had his usual quality outing in attack and defence today. But head coach Mike 'Blade' Blair will have food for thought after the classic curate's egg of a performance. Some flashes of brilliance, some strong performers in defence. But too many unforced errors and a few headless chickens. There are plenty of work-ons, so let's not get too excited.