DEJA VU ALL OVER AGAIN - YET AGAIN - IN NEWPORT
Newportgwentdragons: 32 Edinburgh Rugby: 12
I don't know about you, but I find the Edinburgh Trams strangely fascinating. From my office window in Edinburgh's prestigious West End for a number of years I have watched with interest as the same piece of road has been dug up, filled in and dug up again four times now. Occasionally, there is a frisson of excitement. Some rails have appeared recently. But as the budget has risen inexorably upwards and the finish date been pushed yet further into the future, so the extent of the proposed tramway has shrunk. I really hope that we are not seeing something similar unfolding in the Murrayfield area.
Last year's Rabo finalists, Leinster and the Ospreys, lost just three and five games respectively en route to the grand finale. Embra have managed a hat-trick of losses in the first five matches alone. That is not a good thing. Unless they sort themselves out pronto, they can kiss goodbye to any chance of the playoffs this season. Already, a top four finish is perilously close to the horizon.
Last year, one could be relaxed about Rabo catastrophe given the historic Heineken run, a triumph that has got many in European rugby seeing the Embra men in a new and rather positive light. If this carries on, maybe referees will give the Gunners the usual benefit of the doubt that 'big clubs' tend to get. This year, though, one can and should be significantly less patient with these guys. They have had a big, and I mean BIG, injection of extra budget and have brought in a great deal of quality. The jury may still be out on a couple of them, but in the main they have strengthened the squad significantly and Edinburgh should be well placed to kick on in the international windows - traditionally a torrid time for the club.
They should not be losing to the weakest Welsh region away.
The squad they sent down was strong enough to prevail and should have done so. Rodney Parade has never been a happy hunting ground, the Newporters can tough it out in the trenches with the best of them and all that. But, sorry, this is simply not good enough.
Edinburgh scored two tries - by Brown and I'll leave you to guess the other guy - to only one. But their indiscipline killed them. They coughed up six penalties and a trio of dropped goals to the home side, a poorly defended try for prop Price giving the Newporters 32 points and what turned out to be a pretty comprehensive beating in the end. All the more irritating given that the visitors had started well, Visser putting Brown over early on for a score well converted by Harry Leonard.
Cox and Rennie were carded either side of the half, Newport scoring in the first power play. Quibble about these cardings if you like, as well as the nightmare scenario of John 'Mary-Beth' Lacey on the whistle once again. But the Newporters also had a guy dubiously carded so both sides had to play the referee as best they could. That was not the difference. The difference was, instead, in poor discipline, poor execution, just downright poor altogether. You do not get marks for artistic impression in games such as these. You get victories by getting down and dirty with the other guys and bullying them off the park. This, Edinburgh completely failed to do.
Next up at Murrayfield are Treviso, who have just beaten the high-flying Scarlets. It is not unreasonable to ask for a bit of a reaction on Friday night. But that in itself will not be good enough. Michael's Magic Bus will only make progress if the team selected performs consistently week in, week out.
Some home truths are required in training this week.