Main RSS Feed Forum RSS Feed

Search

Next Fixture

No Upcoming Fixtures Available

Latest Poll

Caullie Lug 16/17




View Results

Log In






Forgot Password

View Article

OH ME OF LITTLE FAITH

Edinburgh: 20 (10) Saracens: 14 (6)



The soundtrack in the car as we returned to the heartland of the Embra Tifosi following this evening's Champions Cup encounter at the DAM Health was The Magnificent Seven by Elmer Bernstein.The Embramen© certainly put in an heroic performance, even though it was largely the home side that were on the attack and high flying Saracens putting in the big shift in defence.  And in the battle of the magnificent sevens, it was the Gunners' Luke 'Bing' Crosbie who came out on top over the visitors' Ben Earl, despite the latter's well taken late try that was to deny Edinburgh a home tie in the round of 16.

I will admit that, at half time, I thought this was going to be another heroic defeat.  Edinburgh had had the lion's share of ball, field position and opportunities against a side that at one point was down to 13 following two - correct - yellow cards for head contact in the tackle.  They had played very well.  But they only had 10 points to show for it.  At one stage, what should have been a 17-3 advantage quickly turned to only 10-6, directly as a result of Embra errors.  On another day, the handling errors and missed kicks would have cost them dear.  But what we saw throughout the match was old school Saracens in defence.  None of this season's groovy total rugby; very little in attack at all, in fact.  They brought grit and endeavour instead, which kept them in this match until the death and, ultimately, delivered the position in Pool A that they wanted.

But it was a great pleasure to be proved completely, utterly, totally, embarrassingly wrong in a DAM Health stadium that was officially rocking.  The Gunners controlled the second half almost as well as they did the first, Star of the March Pierre Schoeman barrelling over for the try that put them 11 points to the good.  This left Sarries chasing the game; a race that ultimately they could not win.

I remember watching Saracens beat Clermont in the Heineken final at BT Murrayfield and thinking that that encounter was, if anything, above Test match intensity.  This evening's affair was a big step up from the URC and the Gunners were the better side. That they should have beaten the form team in the Gallagher Premiership by more will give them plenty of confidence for the remainder of the season and, in particular, the trip to face Leicester at Welford Road in the next round.

'Big' Bill Mata was on fire.  Tiime and again, he smashed well over the gainline, eclipsing Billy Vunipola in the battle of the No 8s.  Sam Skinner has quickly become a key man in the boilerhouse, complementing Grant 'Gilcho' Gilchrist nicely, and showed that again tonight. The set piece was erratic at times, but the pack as a whole fronted up big time and refused to take a backward step.  That clearly rattled Sarries, whose indiscipline under pressure cost them at key moments, despite the presence of Langholm legend Robin 'Bomber' Hislop, who has been a characteristically shrewd acquisiiton for Saracens from the unfortunate events at Wasps.

Further out, starting Ben Vellacott then bringing on the veteran nous of Henry 'H' Pyrgos with 30 minutes still to run proved a coaching masterstroke.  The old boy has been there, done that, and brought vital control in a tight match - immensely frustrating though it may have been to some observers as the ruck speed noticeably slowed.  I thought Henry Immelman had perhaps his best outing in blue and burnt orange.  He was imperious under the high ball, kicked beautifully and showed well in attack.  Despite the back three riches that the Gunners now boast, we are going to miss him when he heads home.  It was great to see Wes 'Moose' Goosen making plenty of metres in attack when he came on, while not only will Charlie Savala and Jack Blain have learned plenty from such a high intensity match, but both performed very well.

For the vast majority of those observers in the capacity crowd of 7,800, this match got off to an absolute dream start. On three minutes, the Embramen unleashed Mata from an attacking lineout.  BBM didn't make it himself, but set up the phases that led to the world's most gorgeous man, Big Dave Cherry©, crashing over.  7-0 Embra and they were off to a flyer. Five minutes later, Blairhorn knocked a penalty over on an evening when The King's place kicking was pretty sound.

Goode did pull back three with a oenalty on 17 minutes, but the first quarter ended with the home side bashing away at the enemy line once again. 

On 21 minutes, Jamie George was yellow carded as a result of attempting to tackle 'Bing' Crosbie standing up, leading to direct head contact.  The hooker came off second best by a distance, but it was a clear card. Without being privy to referee Ludovic Cayre's deliberations, it seemed a fairly passive hit and, therefore, yellow rather than red was surely correct.  Galling for the Lion to be carded as well as disappearing for an HIA, but in all the legalistic debates we tend to get about precisely where a hit has occurred and what constitutes mitigation, sometimes folk can forget that the laws and their interpretation are there for a reason - to protect players.  That's the most important thing.  It was a surprise to see George return to the field later in the half, but no surprise that he did not return after the break.

The Science of Sport podcast on Patreon has a really interesting piece exploring the RFU's recent decision to lower tackle height in the 'community' game. It is free to read and well worth your time: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lowering-legal-77489775  What is most interesting is its account of what has happened in the French community game in recent years, following a slightly different approach adopted there. One result has been coaches have had to accept that certain tactics no longer work.  But they have produced a game that is not only much safer, but also more fun to watch and play in.  Both Saracens' cards were the result of attempts to hold the ball carrier up to create a maul.  It looks increasingly likely that this tactic, born in Ireland, does not have a future.

As it happened, Saracens coped superbly with the power play and even with going down to 13 men when Riccioni was carded for an almost identical hit on Gilchrist.

My half time pessimism was the result of the Embramen's failure to take advantage of the two cards - The King missed a straightforward penalty, while Jamie Ritchie thought he'd scored but lost the ball forward, and they ended the half battering away at the visitors' line but with no joy.  By contrast, Goode managed to knock a penalty over on 39 minutes to leave the score at the break 10-6 Edinburgh.  Sarries had been on the back foot throughout but they would surely show much more in attack in the second period.  It really did feel like the Gunners would rue not having turned pressure into points.

The King was on target again on 44 minutes, though, his second penalty kick stretching the lead to 13-6.  Alex Goode, having missed a straightforward effort, made no mistake on 51 minutes to narrow the gap to four once again. But when Itoje was binned on the hour - a bit of a team card as a result of Sarries' penalty count mounting - there was a real opportunity for the Gunners to go for the jugular.

This they did immediately.  From the resulting penalty knocked to the corner, they put in a series of phases and Schoeman powered over, rapturously acclaimed in the usual manner by the massed Embra Ultras, who put in an impressive performance themselves in support of their team.  20-9 Embra with the conversion at this point and not only victory, but also a home tie in the round of 16 for third place in Pool A was beckoning tantalisingly for the home side.

Edinburgh were doing a pretty good job of running down the clock, The King languidly attempting a long penalty effort that fell just short on 66 minutes.  But Skinner was binned on 73 minutes for a maul offence five metres from the Edinburgh line and Saracens had a lifeline. To their credit, the Gunners managed to clear the immediate danger.  But then replacement prop Eroni Mawi broke from a lineout on the Edinburgh 22 and fed Ben Earl to cruise over in the corner.  Goode missed the conversion to leave the Gunners with a narrow 20-14 advantage.

The Embramen duly held out for the win, but the bonus point conceded left them in fifth position in Pool A, level on 15 points with both Saracens and the Sharks.  They lost out on the basis of tries scored and points difference respectively.  Fine, fine margins. Judging by this evening's performance, they can travel to the Midlands at the end of February with plenty of confidence.  But they will know that matches and placings in this competition are decided by fine margins. They cannot afford to spurn the opportunities they had this evening and hope to progress beyond Welford Road.

Nitpicking is for another day, though.  For now, let's enjoy an excellent, hard fought win, qualification for the Champions Cup knock out rounds, and a raucous DAM Health atmosphere that hopefully will become the norm.