Tichtheid wrote:BigD163 wrote:Friday Knight Lights wrote:Sunday Times reporting we've seen off interest from Gloucester to keep Gilchrist...
Hopefully Cockerill can get the best from him if that is the case, needs to cut out the ridiculous penalties and wear a sensible colour scrum hat.
Interesting. Shows how much the market for him has fallen off. Top tier French clubs to Gloucs wanting to sign him.
There was one stupid lineout penalty on Saturday, but other than that I thought he looked much more like his old self.
He's still only 26, I'd like to see what he brings during a good injury-free run, and I'd much rather he was fit and firing for Edinburgh than anyone else, at his best he is a hell of a player.
Tichtheid wrote:GaryIPA wrote:
need to point out he gave away 4 pens sat
I remember one where he played the opposing jumper's arm, which is one of these things, the stupid one was climbing all over him again at the next lineout, but it did also look like the lifters were at fault on that incident.
If I can bring myself to watch the game again I'll have a look out for the others.
I've never considered Gilcho any kind of penalty magnet.
dolf_lundgren wrote:Toolis can do some of that and Swinson can do some of that but neither provides the security in the scrum that GC can, he is a huge lump and is good at disrupting mauls (sometimes legally)
Edinburgh Shark wrote:Rico wrote:Oldsalt wrote:Don't need a back three player we have enough young talent to bring through. We need a 10 and 12 in the backs.
There's a 10/12 playing for the Blues who's going well by all accounts, and could be worth a look ...
Saints have beaten us to him. Wish him well down there, I think we let a goody away
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 24 guests