Do we get enough value out of him? Should we even consider letting him go? He must be on a big salary and you have to question if his game is developing in the right way.
When he first came on the scene he was great at timing runs and running into space. But instead of focusing on pace and skill he seems to have bulked up and turned into a basher. His kicking and distribution really haven't developed - particularly passing off his left hand. He is also making far too many handling errors. He used to be neck and neck with dunbar for the scotland shirt. Now he is behind dunbar, horne, bennett and duncan taylor at the very least.
Obviously i want to be proved wrong. But as things stand i would be tempted to free up his salary and bring in duncan taylor and huw jones (very talented 21 year old anglo scot at uni in cape town playing super 15 rugby for the stormers) http://www.rugby365.com/article/65908-who-is-huw-jones
Im a fan of matt scott but it's frustrating seeing him going the way he is.