Frenchy wrote:Jockybadger wrote:SHC being the best example of a player "lost"
If Solomons is getting the blame for SHC's loss of form, he has to also get the credit for SHC's fantastic form in the first place. Also Hoyland, Ritchie, Bradbury, Watson, Sutherland etc.
Everything is not Solomons'fault, but I don't really agree.
Many talented players arise here, at Edinburgh. They show us what they are capable of, during six month, one year, one and half year. And then, they stagnate or regress. None of them really flourish. That is due to the awful rugby played here, and to Solomons. Let Kinghorn/Ritchie/Bradbury/Toolis/Hoyland under Solomons during two more years, and they will become ex talented players.
I have to say this is not true for front row players (I'm fair, am I not?). And Watson is an exception. He's unbelievable