Moderators: pedro52, chappo, Ron, Loops
gowrie wrote: Though it does show just how much of a joke our signing policy was last season to leave us in this position.
germain wrote:gowrie wrote: Though it does show just how much of a joke our signing policy was last season to leave us in this position.
I don't know. Beavon, Bryce and Berghan are injured. It's normal to sign a new player as cover.
I thought it was good to have four scottish TH props. We had few problems there, but it's a good effort, and I second it.
Wottie wrote:germain wrote:gowrie wrote: Though it does show just how much of a joke our signing policy was last season to leave us in this position.
I don't know. Beavon, Bryce and Berghan are injured. It's normal to sign a new player as cover.
I thought it was good to have four scottish TH props. We had few problems there, but it's a good effort, and I second it.
Beavon ain't injured, he's apparently just not good enough, which makes him a poor signing. Bryce may be injured but showed in his 5 mins against Munster that he is not ready (or good enough, we don't know yet?). With tighthead one of the most important positions on the pitch (and in knowledge of Nel being rotated and missing for AI's and 6N's), I would say that makes Gowrie pretty much spot on.
germain wrote:Beavon is injured. He's listed on the injury club for the Harlequins game. It's three injured THprop out of four.
Wottie wrote:germain wrote:Beavon is injured. He's listed on the injury club for the Harlequins game. It's three injured THprop out of four.
OK so now he is injured but that means he can't play for Melrose, we have been playing loosheads, academy players and London Scottish props ahead of him when he was fit. He is clearly not up to it.
Return to Edinburgh Rugby Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 40 guests