Moderators: pedro52, chappo, Ron, Loops
macdone wrote:Very frustrating. Our forwards and defence have gone backwards. Our 2 captains are struggling for form which doesn't help.
gowrie wrote:The new attacking gameplan nowhere to be seen, and the reason they could line up so many double tackles is because all we had were isolated forward runners, though at least this time we generally kept our own ruck ball. McCallum got beat up unfortunately, but it'll happen to any TH as they come through, Dell was poor though. Rasolea is in general a heavy lump who can go a metre or two through the gainline and not much else, don't think he's challenging for the first XV. Poor performance in general really but at least they stuck in it til the end, which has been as much as you can say for the side for 3 seasons now.
Frenchy wrote:macdone wrote:Very frustrating. Our forwards and defence have gone backwards. Our 2 captains are struggling for form which doesn't help.
I thought McInally played well today, in the loose at least.
SHC had the best game I remember him having in a long time too. Kinghorn just keeps on impressing.
macdone wrote:Frenchy wrote:macdone wrote:Very frustrating. Our forwards and defence have gone backwards. Our 2 captains are struggling for form which doesn't help.
I thought McInally played well today, in the loose at least.
SHC had the best game I remember him having in a long time too. Kinghorn just keeps on impressing.
McInally is great in the loose, but at 6´3 he has a big problem if the scrum comes under pressure. It's not possible for him to hook. We have one of our captains struggling for form and the other getting beasted in the scrum.
On the plus side, only 2 of those forwards would get in our first choice pack. I can't wait for us to get our best pack on the pitch. Even getting Berghan back would be a bonus.
Friday Knight Lights wrote:macdone wrote:Frenchy wrote:
I thought McInally played well today, in the loose at least.
SHC had the best game I remember him having in a long time too. Kinghorn just keeps on impressing.
McInally is great in the loose, but at 6´3 he has a big problem if the scrum comes under pressure. It's not possible for him to hook. We have one of our captains struggling for form and the other getting beasted in the scrum.
On the plus side, only 2 of those forwards would get in our first choice pack. I can't wait for us to get our best pack on the pitch. Even getting Berghan back would be a bonus.
Which 2? Toolis, Gilchrist, Bradbury and Manu are all arguably first pick.
macdone wrote:Du Preez is our best player, we could really do with his physicality, particularly with Hardie out.
bertie bassett wrote:macdone wrote:Du Preez is our best player, we could really do with his physicality, particularly with Hardie out.
Playing for Heriots today against Hawick.
crabbie wrote:Surely if he's good enough to be in Cotters squad he should be a shoo in for Edinburgh team
Return to Edinburgh Rugby Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 53 guests