Moderators: pedro52, chappo, Ron, Loops
macdone wrote:Slightly surprised by those opinions.
djphilp wrote:It never ceases to amaze me the amount of posters on here who would love for us to get rid of half of our international players just because they aren’t flavour of the month.
I’d have him back in a heart beat. Ford and Cochrane will be lucky to have more than a season left in their legs and personally I’d rather have someone who can push McInally to perform. Turner and McInally could drive each other to higher levels. To those stating that George isn’t the finished article and makes mistakes/has weaknesses let’s not forget that McInally isn’t yet the finished article either despite a great autumn test series.
However after the shoddy treatment with the lack of chances he’s had over the years at Edinburgh I’d be really surprised if he wanted to come back east. If he is to stay in the west I’d agree with Nudger that a swap deal bringing George Horne through to Myreside would be brilliant
djphilp wrote:It never ceases to amaze me the amount of posters on here who would love for us to get rid of half of our international players just because they aren’t flavour of the month.
I’d have him back in a heart beat. Ford and Cochrane will be lucky to have more than a season left in their legs and personally I’d rather have someone who can push McInally to perform. Turner and McInally could drive each other to higher levels. To those stating that George isn’t the finished article and makes mistakes/has weaknesses let’s not forget that McInally isn’t yet the finished article either despite a great autumn test series.
However after the shoddy treatment with the lack of chances he’s had over the years at Edinburgh I’d be really surprised if he wanted to come back east. If he is to stay in the west I’d agree with Nudger that a swap deal bringing George Horne through to Myreside would be brilliant
Return to Edinburgh Rugby Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 67 guests