Moderators: pedro52, chappo, Ron, Loops
dolf_lundgren wrote:In what way has he been shockingly treated? He wasn't deemed as good as the other options and wasn't picked. GT has continued this by picking Ford and McInally ahead of him for Scotland. Im all for giving young players a chance but it has to be merit based.
Also not sure sending him out on loan is any better than not playing him in terms of how a coach rates his play.
Its pro sport and a tough old world. He has taken his chance to an extent with Glasgow but Brown will be straight back in ahead of him when he is fit. His game time for Glasgow tells a lot more about their resources at hooker than ours.
doedin wrote: Good problem to have though, its not too often we end up on this forum debating from a position of riches!
borderflanker wrote:I`m not sure of the welcome he`ll receive if he was to come back as he`s been involved in bust ups with some of our squad members.
biffer wrote:borderflanker wrote:I`m not sure of the welcome he`ll receive if he was to come back as he`s been involved in bust ups with some of our squad members.
?
The Feral Goat wrote:Game for weeg tonight probably a very good example of why he has been behind ERs other three hookers, very good in the loose, not very good in the set piece, brain fart for a yellow which could have been red on a bad ref day.
Think the others do the hooker basics far better and would take that over the loose play which is a bonus really, and I am not sure in rambos case that is not better at present as well.
The Feral Goat wrote:Game for weeg tonight probably a very good example of why he has been behind ERs other three hookers, very good in the loose, not very good in the set piece, brain fart for a yellow which could have been red on a bad ref day.
Think the others do the hooker basics far better and would take that over the loose play which is a bonus really, and I am not sure in rambos case that is not better at present as well.
Return to Edinburgh Rugby Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 45 guests