Friday Knight Lights wrote:Wottie wrote:Weegie59 wrote:Not sure I would take much notice of that pre-match review. Some of the one to one ratings seem bizarre!
Well come on, having gone that far it's normal to elaborate and tell us what you see falling into the bizarre and why?
For me the backs are about correct and forwards a bit harsh on McInally (one of the best in the world and Bismarck is old), Watson (one of the best 7s going) and maybe Ritchie.
I bow to no-one when it comes to my admiration for Rambo - but hear in mind he's onlly about 18 months into this phase of his career of being a top level hooker. Which means I don't think he's at his peak yet. Once he gets there I think we can have the world's best conversation (and I hope the timing works to put him in prime position for a Lions starting jersey in 2.5 years time). BDP set the template for the modern hooker except he's actually built like a front row rather than the converted back row most of the younger guys are! 34 isn't that old for a hooker. One of them on the rise, one declining (from a very high point) so I thought even was a reasonable call.
Camara has been one of the few bright spots for France in recent years. Outstanding physicality whether he's carrying or tackling. It'll be a great battle between these 2. In fact the back row contest could be incredible with the talent on show. Who comes out on top on the night could go a long way to deciding the outcome of the match.
For me one of the keys at 6 is that Ouedraogo has seen and done it all. 320+ top level games. 15th season with Montpellier but still only 32. Still getting the job done. Ritchie's in great form but he's 3rd in line for that 6 shirt for Edinburgh and still learning all the dark arts required to be a really great back row (mind you if he keeps going like he is Barclay might not get a look in and Bradbury may need to be satisfied with understudying for Mata at 8!)
I tried my best! Was maybe concerned about leaning too heavily to the Edinburgh guys having seen more of them in action. Hopefully didn't end up pushing me the other way!