Moderators: pedro52, chappo, Ron, Loops
Friday Knight Lights wrote:Shiel plays well 98% of the time but the 2% is a bad bad decision/mistake. No need to throw that offload.
joe soap wrote:Friday Knight Lights wrote:Shiel plays well 98% of the time but the 2% is a bad bad decision/mistake. No need to throw that offload.
easier to come on and add zip, but that offload is down to trying too hard, often a sign of a player who gets so few chances to impress
Tichtheid wrote:When was the last time you saw no hook called?
Friday Knight Lights wrote:Tichtheid wrote:When was the last time you saw no hook called?
9s are back to squint feeds - when was the last time you saw a straight feed?
Friday Knight Lights wrote:joe soap wrote:Friday Knight Lights wrote:Shiel plays well 98% of the time but the 2% is a bad bad decision/mistake. No need to throw that offload.
easier to come on and add zip, but that offload is down to trying too hard, often a sign of a player who gets so few chances to impress
But he plays a reasonable amount. And he doesn't play more because he always does something mad like throwing blind offloads.
joe soap wrote:Friday Knight Lights wrote:joe soap wrote:easier to come on and add zip, but that offload is down to trying too hard, often a sign of a player who gets so few chances to impress
But he plays a reasonable amount. And he doesn't play more because he always does something mad like throwing blind offloads.
I have seen errors, not seen that offload though
he is 23. been in 21 games, just 5 starts and 2 of those in the challenge cup. Its not enough, if that is what he has merited then could be time to move on.
Return to Edinburgh Rugby Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 61 guests